Preview only · © Willow & Maple Press · All rights reserved

CHAPTER 1

Theressa

Three years later

I get home, kick off my heels, and let out a loud sound of frustration. It’s 8:49 on Friday night and I’ll be spending the rest of the evening alone watching another chick flick.

The girls are gone with Sawyer for the weekend at his parents. They live a few towns away, in Baltimore. Caitlin has hockey there tomorrow.

This dating thing is lame. Maybe I should try making new girlfriends instead. Clearly, there are no decent men left in this city. The guy I met tonight was gross. Has he even heard of a shower? I bet he still lives with his mom. We didn’t even get to that. We didn’t talk about anything real. He just went on and on about his video games and anime. What the hell is that anyway? So, I faked an emergency and left.

Finding new friends is harder than it looks at my age. All the moms from Caitlin’s school are such snobs. I’ll never be friends with any of them. Don’t even get me started with the hockey moms. Maybe Leah will make better friends. Maybe one of them will have a hot single dad. Ha.

I’m spending too much time trying to meet men. Online dating isn’t working out. That’s it. I’m deleting my account.

I log in to deactivate the profile but get caught scrolling for a bit and swiping left at every suggestion. “Gosh, this silly app is so addictive.” I say to myself out loud.

That’s when I get a notification.

A message from Preston Caldwell.

I slam the laptop shut. “I’m not reading it—I’m done!”

I pour a glass of wine and put on Bridget Jones’s Diary. I get comfy with my feet up and Puds curls beside me. I scratch that spot behind his ear he likes.

“You’re such a good puppy. Maybe I don’t need friends. Maybe I’ll just be okay hanging out with my doggy.”

He just looks at me like he wants me to stop talking.

About an hour into the movie, I can’t stop wondering about the unread message. I look at Puds, let out a deep sigh and say, “What do you think? Should I read it? It’s probably some asshole asking if I want to fuck.”

I pour another glass of wine, pick up my phone, and tap it, still debating.

Well, if I want a chance at meeting my man before I’m thirty—ah, what the hell...

When I finally open it, I read:

Preston:
I’ve stared at this screen too long, trying to find the right words, but the truth is—I don’t have perfect words. I just have honesty. And honestly? I never thought I’d be here. I never thought I’d be starting over, trying to build a life again.

Dating apps feel ridiculous, but when I saw your profile, something about you made me pause. Your smile and your beautiful brown curls. Or the way you described yourself—not perfect, not pretending, just real.I lost my wife a few years ago. It’s been me and my son ever since, and I’ve spent so much time making sure he was okay and concentrating on my career that I forgot to take care of myself. But the truth is, I miss having someone to laugh with at the end of the day. I miss simple things—morning coffee with someone who actually understands me, sharing the small joys, feeling like I have a partner again.

I work a lot, I’m a real estate lawyer at BMG law office, hoping it will be BMGC very soon. My son will always be my number one priority. But if you’re willing to take a chance on something real, I’d love to get to know you. No pressure, no expectations—just two people who’ve been through life, sitting down and seeing where a conversation takes us.

hope to hear from you. Maybe I’m too late and you’ve already found ‘your guy’ as you put it. If so, I hope you find the happiness you deserve. But if you’re reading this and willing to take a risk… I’m here.

Preston

My heart melts. Could it really be?

As I read Preston’s message, something unexpected stirs inside me. His words feel... different. Genuine.

For a moment, I imagine what it might be like to be the person he shares those simple joys with.

Nope! Snap out of it, Theressa. He’s probably some douche who used an AI to write the message, expecting to lure me into his bed. An asshole—just like all the others.

I throw a bag of popcorn in the microwave. I grab my phone and message him back.

Theressa:
Are you for real???

I check his profile. Joined a week ago, no stats about returning messages, it must be because he’s new.

He’s hot! —dark, neatly styled hair, piercing blue eyes, a charming, just-crooked-enough smile, and that perfectly trimmed business beard that makes him look like he belongs on the cover of a magazine.

68 km away — not good.
34 years old — good.
Likes hiking and skiing — good, but not likely.
Likes going to the gym — they all say that.
Likes dogs but doesn’t have one — good. Room for mine. Haha.
He’s a lawyer? Doubtful. Although he did put that in his message. He sure looks the part.

He has a son. Okay, doable. But what about the mom? Oh, right—that was in his message too. At least she won’t be in the way. “Damn, what’s wrong with me,” I mutter under my breath.

Mike, the only guy I seriously dated since Sawyer, dumped me to crawl back to his wife, so excuse me for being a little skeptical.

His message was very detailed. It didn’t seem like forced charm or recycled pickup lines. Just a man sharing his truth. He’s been through loss, yet there’s warmth in his tone. The way he describes craving laughter and morning coffee with someone—it makes me pause.

Why rush? I’m not going to be married before I’m thirty, like I always planned. I’m caught up on meeting someone because I’m about to turn the big 3-O. I have my kids and I don’t want any more. I don’t need a man to be happy. I’m sick of the poor quality of men I find on these sites. I’m going to wait for the universe to introduce us the old-fashioned way.

I put down my phone, grab my wine and popcorn, and return to my movie.

My phone buzzes.

Preston:
Sorry, I’m new to this and not sure what I’m doing. I guess that message sounded really desperate. It truly was ‘for real’.
Preston:
My sister is making fun of me so bad right now!
Preston:
I’m really not looking for a hook-up. It’s not for me.
Theressa:
You better not be messing with me. I have things to do, and wasting time on some jerk, isn’t how I want to be spending my Friday night.

The dots keep appearing like he’s typing, then they disappear. This happens a few times. Hmm. He’s new to this and it sounds like he hasn’t dated since his wife. I’m not sure if that’s a good or a bad thing.

Theressa:
Here’s how you should approach a girl…

I start giving him tips about how to use the dating app. Girls want this, girls want that, blah blah blah. I exaggerate the humour, so he doesn’t take me seriously.

Preston:
Oh, that sounds dreamy, lol.

I like how he reacts, so I keep going—sharing some of my worst dating disasters, ending with tonight’s charming gem who wouldn’t shut up about video games…

Theressa:
I don’t understand why people waste their time with video games. Especially adults. Who even has time for that?

He starts typing. Stops. Starts again. Then, finally—

Preston:
Can I call you?

Uh…okay, I’m freaking out, I close my phone and hide it under the throw pillow. Out of sight, out of mind. Sort of.

I’ll just go to bed. That way, I can say I fell asleep—technically not a lie if I do it fast enough.

Wait—what if he’s offended that I fell asleep? I can’t leave him hanging…

Theressa:
I’m about to go to sleep. It’s been a day! Maybe tomorrow?
Preston:
Sure, good night. Sleep well.

Oh, my! No, Theressa. You have to stop thinking he might be the one! I tell myself. I take out a book to read as a distraction until I fall asleep.

Saturday morning.

I wake up and check my phone. There’s already a message from Preston Caldwell.

It’s his phone number.

I text him right away:

Theressa:
Good morning, thanks for your phone number. I deleted my account this morning—but don’t be too flattered. I was trying to delete it yesterday. That’s when I got your message.

Ugh. That’s the worst message ever. I should have written something charming or interesting.

Theressa:
It’s Theressa btw

Crap! It sounds like I’m not interested. Or desperate. Maybe that’s because I am?

Theressa:
Also, I’m done with the app but okay with seeing where this goes.

Oh, no. Unsend. Unsend. …Shit. Whatever. I’m done! It’s best if he doesn’t write back anyway.

I’m not going back on the app. This is it.

I’ll be thirty, single, and thriving—because happiness isn’t a relationship status. It’s a mindset.

I put on music and start Saturday morning chores. I’m getting an early start since I don’t have to be at hockey with Caitlin.

Sawyer texted that they made it on time, so I don’t have to worry. I’m happy that he’s good about keeping me informed when he has the girls. He’s pretty good with them, he’s just not around very often, and he rarely takes them overnight. He lives in a bachelor’s apartment on base, it’s not really suitable.

It’s almost lunchtime, I check my phone again. No news from Preston yet. Figures.

I toss my phone on the couch and keep moving. I sing along with the music, trying to distract myself and focus on that whole happiness mindset thing.

Then, I catch in the corner of my eye, my phone lighting up.

A message.

I almost dive over the couch to retrieve my phone. I’m so excited. I hope it’s from him—please let it be from Preston.

Preston:
Hi! I was driving when I got your message this morning, so I couldn’t write back. I didn’t want to read out loud or voice text, my son was in the car. Seeing a text from an unknown number had to be from you, so it put a smile on my face for the rest of the day.
Preston:
Jayce had a martial art competition today… It was really eventful. Marion was beside me the whole time, and I didn’t want her to get involved in our conversation.
Theressa:
Marion?
Preston:
My sister.

Oh. She’s always with them?!

Theressa:
Your son’s name is Jayce? How old is he?
Preston:
He’s 8. How old are your kids? You have two girls, right?

I bite my lip, staring at the screen a moment longer before typing back.

Theressa:
Yes, girls, 8 and 4, both going on 16, it seems at times. Both emotional hurricanes with glitter addictions.
Preston:
We both have an 8-year-old. Maybe it’s a sign… lol.
Theressa:
A sign or just statistically probable?
Preston:
But you’ve got twice the sass at home.
Theressa:
Twice the sass, three times the drama, and absolutely no peace.
Preston:
That sounds… terrifying.
Theressa:
And yet you’re still texting me. Brave man.

We text back and forth while I’m getting ready. Cheryl, my college roommate, is in town visiting family for the long weekend. For once, I don’t have the kids and we’re taking full advantage. She moved away not long after we graduated, so we rarely get to hang out.

Preston:
But this… talking to you? This is a nice change.
Theressa:
Honestly, this is the calmest moment I’ve had all week.

I smile at the screen while brushing mascara onto my lashes. I forgot how nice it felt—this kind of conversation, light and effortless.

Theressa:
Same here. I’ve got to run, meeting a friend. But I’ll text you later, okay?
Preston:
Looking forward to it.

Sunday morning.

I wake up to another text.

Preston:
I hope you had a good time with your friend last night. I’m going for a hike with Jayce. Text you later.
Theressa:
Hope you have an awesome time!

He mentioned they typically do something outdoorsy on Sundays. he seems like the kind of dad who always has a backpack half-packed and snacks in the glovebox.

By midday, my phone buzzes again—and this time, he gets right to the point.

Preston:
My sister just agreed to watch Jayce this evening. If you’re free for dinner?
Theressa:
Tonight? Ok, I’m free. Where can I meet you?
Preston:
Martha’s? 7pm?
Theressa:
Perfect! See you then.

I love Martha’s. Points for good taste in restaurants — Yay.

I cringe at my own internal cheer. He hasn’t even opened a door or offered me his jacket yet and I’m already getting too optimistic. Chill, Theressa.

It’s just dinner. No big deal.

Still… I put on my best date outfit—the one that reveals just enough but not like I’m trying too hard. Just in case. Because maybe—just maybe—this one will be different.

What if, I’m getting fooled again. What was I thinking? I should cancel. I’ve gone out every night this weekend, I’ll just end up being tired all week.

Bad dates have a way of lowering your expectations. And mine are already pretty low—even with my guard up.

But I haven’t been this curious about someone in a long time, probably ever.

End of Chapter 1

Keep reading

That was chapter one. The rest of What He Doesn't Remember is waiting.

Kindle Paperback Kobo

Before you go

Know when the next one lands

Kali's newsletter brings early chapters, release dates and where to find her next — straight from her, a few times a year.

Join the newsletter